What happens to local journalism on a three-day print cycle?

16 Jan

This morning the company I work for, Digital First Media, announced that one of our daily newspapers, the Oneida Daily Dispatch in upstate New York, will switch to a three-day publishing cycle.

Our employees and readers in Connecticut might be wondering if this is a possibility for the New Haven Register, The Register Citizen or The Middletown Press. The short answer is, “I don’t know,” “unlikely in the immediate future,” and “I’m not afraid of it if that day comes.”doc50f59b969b35b491839571

In the past, print circulation revenue’s share of the pie vs. advertising revenue has scuttled discussions of reducing print frequency of our dailies in Connecticut. I’ve done the math.

But that math is changing across the country, and if the day comes when it makes more sense for us to publish five days, or three days, instead of seven, why wouldn’t we make that switch?

The impetus for change in Oneida came from a competitor’s switch to three days. The Advance Publications daily in Syracuse is switching to three days, and we contract with Syracuse to print and deliver the Oneida Daily Dispatch.

Considering the difficulty of finding a new printer and distributor, we did the math on our own switch to three days and it made sense.

Here are the other reasons it makes sense:

Unlike what you might have heard about the New Orleans Times-Picayune‘s switch to three days, where local journalism resources were gutted, newsroom staffing in Oneida will remain intact.

At the same time, our newsrooms in Connecticut are taking over page layout for the new three-day Oneida print edition. With the same size staff, and no print edition layout sapping the resources of a small newsroom anymore, Oneida will have significantly more resources than before to devote to local journalism.

Oneida’s staff plans to use this new capacity to do more local enterprise and investigative reporting, more comprehensive coverage of local government and new local human interest features.

In considering this issue about reducing print frequency, note that the web audience of newspapers such as the Oneida Daily Dispatch, Register Citizen and Middletown Press is six or seven times the size of their print editions. The launch over the past year of iPad and iPhone/Android apps in Oneida and our other daily newspaper markets is causing that gap to accelerate. Our local news coverage is being introduced to a significantly wider audience through mobile and tablet platforms. In Oneida, those apps present a dynamic alternative for consuming local news as print frequency is reduced.

With the increase in breaking, multimedia and interactive local news coverage, the daily print edition is more and more “outdated.” Printing seven days is about a declining print readership habit, not at all about timeliness of news delivery.

The big question is whether local journalism will improve, decline or stay the same when dailies make this switch to three days.

It’s exciting to see Oneida take a different path than New Orleans by maintaining staffing and being freed up to do better local journalism as part of this switch.


2 Responses to “What happens to local journalism on a three-day print cycle?”

  1. Martin Langeveld (@MartinLangeveld) January 17, 2013 at 9:53 am #

    The switch in Oneida is being done for solid strategic reasons, and the announcement was well-framed and forward-looking. In New Orleans there were definite economic factors (city population had plummeted), though some of the other Advance conversions were more strategic. If we get a few more of these conversions without layoffs as part of the picture, the attitude of both the public and of newsrooms may become more positive about them. (Other departments whose work is outsourced will not be as copacetic, but most of the buggy-whip makers and coal locomotive stokers were laid off, too.) As noted in my recent NiemanLab article, we’re going to see many more of these conversions, one way or the other, because you can’t have a seventh year of declining revenue, vanishing print readership, coupled with the prospect of near-universal smartphone and tablet ownership — a perfect storm, all in all — without looking at structural changes. These factors will probably challenge even the 3-day model in a few years.

  2. Alltranscript.com January 17, 2013 at 10:51 pm #

    Interesting post. Normally these days for reading news and staying update on any niche general information, we are more likely to go to online news sites. I think the trend is likely to continue specifically with the new generation of people coming referring to online sites for research and news. It would be interesting to see how the local journalism improves by switching over to this 3 day per week model. My guess is – Slightly decline in the short term and then increasing rate of decline in the long term.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: